Witch's Grave: St. Thomas, Ontario
Why do people create Witch stories like this? This is very unlikely to be a Witch's grave. If there had been rumours about her being a Witch she would not have been given space in this cemetery (Old St. Thomas Church) at all.
The reality is, she was a young wife who died giving birth to a daughter who also died a few months afterwards. I read about this grave and what I did wonder is why she was given such an elaborate grave marker. That's the more interesting story.
Maria Baldwin (nee Ermatinger) 1840 - 1863, was the daughter of Edward Ermatinger, the owner and editor of the St. Thomas Standard newspaper, he was later elected to Parliament. Her Mother was Achsah "Axie" Burnham Ermatinger. Maria was the wife of Reverend Maurice Baldwin, who later became Bishop of Huron. Her husband did remarry and had a daughter who survived.
Maria's isn't the only grave for her family in this graveyard. There is another grave with a tall stone for the Ermatinger family. Maria had six siblings, one who died as an infant. One of her brothers, Charles, became a lawyer then a senior judge. Charles wrote about Canadian history and was the President of the Elgin County Historical Society. Two of her sisters also died at the age of 22. Several of her siblings are buried near the grave for their Uncle, Frances “Francois” Ermatinger. Frances was a fur trader with the Hudson's Bay Company who married a native woman. The Ermatinger family had come to Canada from Portugal.
So what was special about Maria that she was given this grave with that carved, tall marker of her own? I don't know. Maybe she was just a lovely young women, especially missed and family wanted to do more for her as a memorial. The four posts around the grave were support for a chain which was meant to keep anyone from crossing over her plot. The family grave doesn't have this. I think there was just something special about Maria and she was a much loved daughter, sister and wife.
The Witch’s grave is an old black grave, grand and tall with four black posts surrounding it, in St. Thomas, Ontario. I came upon it awhile back by accident, when exploring the Old St. Thomas Church and its adjacent graveyard. At the time, I didn’t realize that the Witch’s grave was called the “Witch’s grave” nor that it had urban legends associated with it. I just thought it was a really cool grave. Soon, however, I learned that Maria Ermatinger’s grave was the subject of much local lore and ghostly tales.
Several locals kindly took the time to recount the tales they had been told so many times. Some legends tell that Maria was a wealthy but mean and stingy woman in her time and that the townspeople burned her grave out of spite. It is said that if you step beyond the four posts guarding her grave, you will certainly be cursed! It is also said that the black cat that often roams the graveyard has been alive since Maria’s time and watches over her grave. Other tales say that Maria was a witch and that her grave bursts into flames every Hallowe’en.
Maria’s story is quite tragic, although common for her time. Maria Ermatinger died 11 days after childbirth due to infection. Maria had been married to Reverend Maurice Baldwin.
Maria had indeed been wealthy, a child of old money. Maria had an elaborate burial, her body brought in by a team of white horses. Her tombstone had been specially ordered from a company in Toronto and was made of white sandstone. Four white sandstone posts with attaching chains were erected around her grave as a sign of her family’s wealth. The posts also helped prevent people from stepping on her grave and causing the ground to sink which was common occurrence in those days.
There is no historical documentation that Maria was ever accused of witchcraft. Furthermore, the church guide I spoke to said that no one “proven” to be a witch would have been buried in a churchyard. As well, the grave is black because the particular grave product that Maria’s family ordered turns black after years of oxidation. Apparently many black tombstones made of the same material exist in Toronto.
As for the cat, who knows – I heard his/her name is “Spook” and he/she certainly looks well cared for. WHY?
So, why? Why has Maria Ermatinger’s grave become an urban legend? Why has Maria been vilified as a witch and a stingy mean woman when no historical fact supports any such accusations? Well, to start, I found that there are many “Witch’s graves”.
Urban legends often arise to explain the unknown and deal with our fears. In these cases, our fear is of the unknown and of that which is different. This is also known as xenophobia – perceiving safety in that which is most like us and danger in that which is different.
Clearly, Maria’s grave being black and large with four posts surrounding it and a black cat guarding it has made it different enough to spawn an urban legend. However, I wonder if it really began after her death – was she so wealthy that she was different enough to fear? Or maybe her dying after childbirth tainted her and made her the feared “other”. I doubt these last two, but nonetheless wonder.
Please feel free to drop me a line if you visit Maria’s grave, or have heard a legend about it I haven’t told. Let me know too if you were brave (or foolish) enough to step inside the four posts. I didn’t!
Comments:
kvdkooy said...
I used to work at that church (1993-1999). The cat belonged to the owners of the bed & breakfast next door. He wandered around the grave yard and we let him into the church to help with the mice. The cat you have pictured isn't the original Spooky though (Her head was always cocked to the side). It's most likely Spook II. The cats must have been left behind when they moved out.Emily Norton said...
The first time I heard about this was from my Dad, he had told me that the woman had cursed a man who she previously warned not to take her son (or some young man, perhaps a nephew - it was a long time ago) out fishing, the man proceeded to do so and the boy died. And his family also started to die after the fact, and he eventually killed himself.Now I actually just visited the grave site a few hours ago and went inside the pillars (creepy, I know) and saw that she really had a daughter who died at 9 months.
So the only conclusion I have come to that the accusations are false. Although she was mean, some people are, she was just a woman who had a baby and died. She was the Reverend's wife too, so it is a little disrespectful to accuse her of that, I'm sure the Reverend chose a suitable wife to show the church.
And to the previous commenter, the text on the base of the grave stone said "Toronto" (which was the only legible part). Which just must be where it was from.
All in all I don't think she was a witch, and if you are superstitious, just be respectful, she was human.
Anonymous said...
I live a couple streets away from this graveyard. It is one of my favourite places and has been since I was a small child. I have always love that stone, and many others there.I was told that the woman was accused of being a witch because she practiced medicine with natural herbs and stuff like that. Nothing dangerous, just different. I was always told she was misunderstood and the rest of the town took advantage of that and they killed her.
There were also black chains hanging from the posts. I remember. I have pictures of them from when I was younger. I was told that if any male had walked past the posts he would be cursed for life. Because it was the men of the town who murdered her.
I have walked past the posts many times. Touched the stone and taken it's picture. I love the stone and love hearing all the stories people were told about it.
Terrance Gibson said...
The St. Thomas "witches grave" legend appears to have expanded into a number of detailed variants over the years and what I'm about to say may disappoint some, but alas, the origin of the story is much more mundane than you might expect. This tale began as a prank yarn concocted by a local resident about the grave, and the woman buried there and first circulated in the community around 1986. It was completely devised out of thin air by a St. Thomas father and told to his fifteen year old teenage son, who attended Arthur Voaden Secondary School in the city at the time. I know these details because I witnessed the entire thing. The rather gullible young man repeated the tale verbatim to a number of his friends at school, who promptly passed it on to others. It has simply grown from there. I clearly remember in the original telling, the dark colour of the tombstone was explained as being a result of a "lightning strike" on the monument, brought on by the "evil" nature of the "witch" buried there. All total nonsense of course, as you point out it's a result of oxidation of the stone over time and Maria the women buried there, is simply a sad case of a minister's wife who died as a result of childbirth. It appears that what began as a joke twenty five years ago has definitely grown "legs".@Terrance - thanks so much for your history, it is fascinating to me how urban legends get formed and then proliferate.
You're welcome Heather. The four small cast iron pillars that surround the grave were actually linked together at one time with lengths of chain, which apparently either rusted away to the point where the cemetery removed them or they were stolen by vandals. I recall that in the original telling of the story, the "curse" you refer to above was supposedly brought down upon anyone who stepped over those chains onto the grave itself. I remember being quite surprised, at the time, at how quickly some local teenagers appeared to be intrigued by the story and began leaving evidence of night time visits to the grave in the form of leaving behind the remains of burned out candles and trinkets. This was especially evident the following Halloween. Unfortunately, in all likelihood, these night time visits also explain the spate of vandalism that occurred in the cemetery during the same period. Sadly, that's exactly why stories regarding some rather interesting sites are often suppressed by their caretakers.
Terrance Gibson
Emily Memily said...
Emily Norton-
The rumor about the son who wasn't supposed to go out to see is the Chrisholm plot, which is in the far back of the same graveyard. Legend has it that the father of that family wrecked his ship, and locals went out to help. One of these locals was a widows son (not buried in the graveyard), and she warned him not to go help. Her son died, and his body came ashore at the same time Captain Crisholm washed up on the beach. She cursed Chrisholm. As seen on the family grave site, none of his children survived past the age of 30.Nothing to do with the witches grave, but it is a common misconseption as the cat likes to hang around this grave as well as the grave of the Ponsford children.
Source: Exploration Project (Heather in southern Ontario)
Maria Ermatinger Baldwin was born into a prosperous family. Her father, Edward Ermatinger, was the owner and editor of the St. Thomas Standard newspaper and was later elected to Parliament. Maria was one of seven children and at the age of just twenty, she married the reverend of the church where she would later be buried, Maurice Baldwin. The couple moved to Port Dover to begin their life together and Maria was soon pregnant with their first child. That’s where her story ends. Like many women of the time, Maria died from complications of childbirth. She was twenty-two years old. She returned to St. Thomas in a funeral carriage.
The inscription on Maria’s tombstone would have you believe that being her father’s daughter and her husband’s wife were the defining features of her short life. Her mother, Axie, is not mentioned in the inscription, nor are her sisters, Annie and Frances (who also died at twenty-two.) They are buried nearby, under an impermeable metal monument that did not blacken with age or weather.
Source: Liminal Sister - Witchs Grave
We look at the Witch's Grave located in the Old St. Thomas Cemetery at the Old St. Thomas Church in Ontario. This is the most famous grave in the yard belonging to Maria Baldwin. Rumours began in 1970 that she was a mean woman and a witch, and that her gravestone was black due to fires lit by local residents out of spite, as well as every Halloween. Also, anyone who enters inside the 4 black posts that surround the grave would be cursed. It is also rumoured that there is a black cat that roams the cemetery since her death to protect her.
The reality is that Maria's grave is black from acid rain over the years and railway soot as the gravestone was made of white sandstone brought in from Toronto which was very expensive. This is a very porous material which can turn black easily.
Maria died at the young age of 22 in 1863 due to complications with child birth. Her baby died 9 months later and they are both buried together in this grave.
Source: YouTube from TikiTrex: This is The Witch's Grave